How to Publish an Article for Free
August 2, 2025
Elsevier vs MDPI: Which Publisher Should You Choose? (2026-2027)
August 2, 2025
Every so often a student forwards me an email promising guaranteed publication in a Scopus-indexed journal within days, and asks whether it's genuine. It never is, and I want to explain exactly why, not just tell you to be suspicious.
Peer review is the whole point of academic publishing. It exists precisely so that acceptance can't be promised in advance, by anyone, for any fee. If a service is offering that guarantee, the guarantee itself is the red flag.
What we can offer is real experience. Our editors have supported hundreds of successful journal submissions over the years, and they know exactly what a desk editor looks for before a paper even reaches peer review.
Updated August 2026, for the 2026 to 2027 publishing cycle. Written by Katherine Alexander, PhD, UK Academic Editor at Premier Dissertations.
Why Guaranteed Acceptance Is Always a Red Flag
Legitimate journals assess manuscripts for originality, methodology, and relevance through independent peer review. That process can't be fast-tracked or promised in advance, because the outcome genuinely isn't known until reviewers have actually read the work.
Predatory publishers exploit exactly the pressure that makes this tempting, tight thesis deadlines, promotion requirements, or simply wanting to see your name in a journal. They target researchers who are new to publishing, or who need visibility in Scopus or Web of Science quickly, with unsolicited emails promising publication in days and, sometimes, forged acceptance letters.
How to Identify a Predatory Journal
| Red flag | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Guaranteed or near-instant acceptance | Real journals never promise this before peer review |
| Unsolicited, flattering invitation email | Legitimate journals don't cold-solicit submissions this way |
| Fabricated or unverifiable editorial board | Names are often invented or used without consent |
| Hidden or surprise fees after acceptance | Reputable journals disclose every fee upfront |
| Fake impact factor claims | Watch for made-up metrics like "Global Impact Factor," not a real index |
| Journal name closely mimics a real one | Often a deliberate imitation, sometimes hijacking, see below |
One red flag alone isn't always damning, but three or more together is a strong signal to walk away.
Journal Hijacking
This is a specific and increasingly common fraud, separate from a journal simply having a similar-sounding name. A hijacked journal clones the actual website, ISSN, and branding of a real, reputable journal, then collects submissions and fees under that stolen identity. Often the cloned site differs from the genuine one by a single letter, a hyphen, or a different domain extension.
Always check the exact URL against the journal's listing in DOAJ or its publisher's own site before submitting, never just the name you were sent.
How to Actually Verify a Journal
- Run it through Think.Check.Submit. A free, cross-industry checklist built for exactly this.
- Check its status directly in DOAJ. Don't trust a badge on the journal's own site, verify independently.
- Check COPE membership. Membership in the Committee on Publication Ethics is a genuine trust signal, not a guarantee, but a real one.
- Confirm indexing at the source. Search the Scopus Source List or Web of Science Master Journal List directly rather than trusting the journal's own claim.
- Search the editorial board's names individually on Google Scholar. Do they exist, publish in the field, and actually list this journal?
- Ask your supervisor or a librarian. They've usually seen the specific journal or publisher before, and are worth the two-minute conversation.
If You've Already Submitted to a Suspicious Journal
Try to withdraw the paper before it's published, most journals have a formal withdrawal process, even predatory ones. If it's already published, don't reuse or resubmit the same content elsewhere, that creates a separate problem. Talk to your supervisor or your institution's research office, they've dealt with this before and can advise on the specific situation.
Not Sure If a Journal You've Been Approached By Is Legitimate?
Send me the journal's name and I'll help you check it properly before you commit anything.
Or visit: Choosing the Right Journal → · Scopus Publication Support →
Tell Us Where You Want to Publish. We Handle Everything Else.
You don't need to become an expert in journal fees or manuscript formatting. That's what I'm here for.
Journal selection →
A free, personalised shortlist based on your field and priorities.
Editing and proofreading →
A full line edit before you spend anything on submission fees.
Full publishing support →
Cover letters, submission formatting, and tracking through to a decision.
Journal acceptance can never be guaranteed by any service. The decision belongs to the journal's editors and reviewers.
💬 Just get in touch →Trusted by 15,000+ UK and international students
What Researchers Say About Our Publishing Support
Feedback from researchers who've used our editing and pre-submission review.
Last reviewed: August 2026 · Reviewed by UK Academic Editor, PhD
